Skip to content

Application: Kelmarsh wind farm

Ten-minute SCADA data of the six Senvion MM92 turbines of Kelmarsh wind farm (UK): Plumley, C. & Takeuchi, R., Kelmarsh wind farm data, Zenodo, doi:10.5281/zenodo.16807551, CC-BY-4.0, downloaded at run time. The data set was chosen by a screening with an approval criterion fixed before the analysis; the study was then repeated on all six turbines under a protocol also fixed before the run. The full material is in comparison/applications/ (README, screening.py, kelmarsh_case_study.ipynb, kelmarsh_all_turbines.py). Numbers are reported without interpretation.

Screening criterion

A candidate passes if, with p = 2 components, the mean out-of-sample VAF of qlPCA with 1 or with 2 interior knots is at least 5 percentage points higher than the mean out-of-sample VAF of linear PCA (n_knots=0) on the same data and folds. The results for p = 3 and the in-sample VAF are reported but do not enter the decision. The numbers are reported without interpretation.

If Kelmarsh does not pass, the same procedure is repeated with Hill of Towie.

All turbines: protocol

Fixed on 2026-11-15, before any computation on turbines 2 to 6. Implemented in kelmarsh_all_turbines.py (notebook kelmarsh_all_turbines.ipynb); results in results/ with the prefix all_.

  1. Turbines and years. Kelmarsh 1 to 6; analysis year 2019; boundary year 2018. The pipeline of the Kelmarsh 1 case study is applied without changes: the same 8 variables (wind speed, power, rotor speed, pitch angle, nacelle, generator, gearbox and ambient temperatures); the same filter (remove records overlapping Stop or Communication events, Power <= 0 and missing values; keep records overlapping Warning events, flagged warning_active); a sample of 2000 records with numpy.random.default_rng(2026); 5 contiguous time blocks; the same out-of-sample VAF criterion (test rows clipped to the training range); gains paired by block.
  2. Boundaries. B1 to B4 are estimated on 2018 for each turbine with the same method (medians by wind classes of 0.5 m/s with at least 30 records; thresholds at 5 % of the range of each median; B3 searched above the wind of the minimum pitch median). They are reported in a table per turbine.
  3. Exclusion rule. A turbine is excluded only if, in 2019 or in 2018, it has fewer than 20 000 records after filtering, or if any of the boundaries cannot be estimated. Exclusions and their reason are reported.
  4. Models per turbine (p = 2): PCA; percentiles with 2 knots per variable; percentiles with the same number of interior knots per variable as the control-region model; control regions (2018); the last two also with monotone=True.
  5. Main results. (a) per turbine, the paired difference "control regions minus percentiles with the same number of knots" and its standard error over the 5 blocks, in the unrestricted and the monotone versions; (b) the number of turbines in which that difference is positive; (c) the mean of the differences over the turbines and its standard error between turbines (sd / sqrt(number of turbines)). Also reported: the gain of each model over PCA; the correlation between rotor speed and generator speed per turbine (to confirm that dropping generator speed applies to all); the number of start-up / idle records below B1 (pitch > 5° or rotor speed < 8.0 rpm) and the gain of the control-region model without them; whether the segments below B1 of wind speed, power and rotor speed are decreasing in each turbine.
  6. Sensitivity. The results of (a) without the warning_active records.
  7. Check. Kelmarsh 1 must reproduce the case study (paired gain of the control-region model over PCA 10.97; difference control regions minus percentiles with the same number of knots 1.98). If it does not, the run stops.

Figures: the difference (a) per turbine with error bars, unrestricted and monotone; the 2018 operating curves of the six turbines with B1 to B4. Numbers are reported without interpretation.

All turbines: results

Run with kelmarsh_all_turbines.py under the protocol above. Check: Kelmarsh 1 reproduces the case study (paired gain of the control-region model over PCA 10.97; difference 1.98). No turbine excluded: records after filtering 45 567 – 47 921 in 2019 and 44 044 – 45 990 in 2018; all boundaries estimated.

Boundaries (2018), wind speed in m/s, and the rotor-speed and pitch thresholds:

turbine B1 B2 B3 B4 B1 threshold (rpm) B3 threshold (deg)
Kelmarsh 1 4.351 8.625 9.553 10.771 8.492 0.713
Kelmarsh 2 4.335 8.528 9.545 10.572 8.490 0.771
Kelmarsh 3 4.620 8.704 9.474 10.632 9.303 0.718
Kelmarsh 4 4.389 8.630 9.590 10.726 8.491 0.714
Kelmarsh 5 4.322 8.575 9.407 10.668 8.492 0.627
Kelmarsh 6 4.513 8.739 9.374 10.811 9.303 0.615

In Kelmarsh 3 and 6 the lowest rotor-speed median of 2018 is about 9 rpm, against about 8.1 rpm in the other four (figure all_operating_curves_2018). The control-region model has 4, 4, 2, 2 interior knots for wind, power, rotor and pitch and 2 per temperature in every turbine (28 parameters; the same-number percentile model 27).

Paired gain over PCA, out of sample (VAF points; se over the 5 blocks in brackets):

model K1 K2 K3 K4 K5 K6
percentile knots 8.53 (1.97) 11.93 (1.92) 8.04 (2.35) 11.45 (2.30) 10.60 (2.42) 7.88 (2.45)
percentiles, same number of knots 8.98 (2.06) 12.77 (1.90) 8.68 (2.33) 12.22 (2.31) 11.21 (2.45) 8.36 (2.42)
percentiles, same number of knots, monotone 6.87 (1.10) 9.97 (0.73) 6.87 (1.66) 8.93 (0.81) 7.25 (1.14) 5.85 (1.83)
control regions (2018) 10.97 (2.15) 13.30 (1.84) 11.48 (2.76) 13.09 (2.09) 12.36 (1.53) 11.78 (3.22)
control regions (2018), monotone 10.02 (1.80) 12.06 (1.44) 10.23 (2.49) 11.40 (1.61) 11.04 (1.40) 10.27 (3.02)

Out-of-sample VAF of PCA: 71.95, 69.42, 69.55, 69.14, 68.85, 69.93.

Main results: control regions minus percentiles with the same number of knots (paired over the 5 blocks):

turbine unrestricted monotone unrestricted, without warning_active monotone, without warning_active
Kelmarsh 1 1.98 (0.43) 3.15 (0.72) 2.03 (0.51) 3.03 (0.81)
Kelmarsh 2 0.54 (0.70) 2.09 (0.80) 0.53 (0.71) 2.08 (0.81)
Kelmarsh 3 2.80 (0.94) 3.36 (0.85) 2.79 (0.95) 3.34 (0.83)
Kelmarsh 4 0.87 (1.07) 2.48 (0.93) 0.78 (0.75) 2.43 (0.98)
Kelmarsh 5 1.15 (1.51) 3.79 (0.52) 1.04 (1.59) 3.70 (0.53)
Kelmarsh 6 3.42 (1.37) 4.42 (1.38) 3.43 (1.36) 4.43 (1.38)
(b) positive 6 of 6 6 of 6 6 of 6 6 of 6
(c) mean (se between turbines) 1.79 (0.47) 3.21 (0.35) 1.77 (0.48) 3.17 (0.35)

Records flagged warning_active in the 2000-record samples: 365, 1, 1, 81, 3, 1.

Other facts per turbine:

turbine corr(rotor, generator) records below B1 start-up/idle below B1 control-region gain without them (se) lowest segments of wind / power / rotor
Kelmarsh 1 1.0000 348 26 7.88 (0.75) decreasing / decreasing / decreasing
Kelmarsh 2 1.0000 376 35 9.98 (1.67) decreasing / decreasing / decreasing
Kelmarsh 3 1.0000 480 34 8.36 (2.65) decreasing / decreasing / decreasing
Kelmarsh 4 0.9999 361 42 9.30 (1.62) decreasing / decreasing / decreasing
Kelmarsh 5 1.0000 451 35 8.81 (1.26) decreasing / decreasing / decreasing
Kelmarsh 6 1.0000 548 49 8.06 (2.11) decreasing / decreasing / decreasing

Correlations to four decimals. The start-up/idle definition (pitch > 5° or rotor < 8.0 rpm) is the one fixed in the protocol; it was not adapted to the 9 rpm rotor-speed floor of Kelmarsh 3 and 6.

Files: all_inclusion.csv, all_boundaries.csv, all_vaf.csv, all_differences.csv, all_turbine_facts.csv, all_summary.json; figures all_differences, all_operating_curves_2018 (PDF and PNG).

Figures

Control regions in 2018 (medians in 0.5 m/s wind classes and the boundaries B1–B4), six turbines:

Operating curves 2018

Control regions minus percentiles with the same number of knots, per turbine (± standard error over the 5 blocks):

Differences per turbine

Kelmarsh 1, 2019 sample by control region:

Operating regimes, Kelmarsh 1

Kelmarsh 1, piecewise loadings of the control-region model:

Piecewise loadings

Kelmarsh 1, records below B1 by membership of the decreasing segments (start-up / idle records marked ×):

Decreasing branch